BPattern B

The Boring Work Was Never the Job

Peter Cleary · · 3 min read

#core-skills#ai-capabilities#human-in-the-loop

Many knowledge workers sit in fear that AI will take over their jobs. What AI is actually good at is the boring work that you had to do to make sure the hard, exciting and creative work resulted in something.

And - for product management - AI already has the capability to do a lot of the work we used to do by hand: summarizing notes from interviews, supplementing end-user observations with user-monitoring data, writing a Jira ticket, creating a deck for an executive presentation.

Core skills still matter - maybe even more - today than they did a few years ago. Writing a Jira ticket doesn’t separate a good from a great product manager. It’s what happens before and after the ticket is written that matters. AI can supplement that, but it can’t replace it.

Three skills I don’t think will stay fully in the human realm are strategic thinking, deep market understanding and aligning engineers toward a shared focus and goal. Yes, these are more complex skills, but I think AI will eventually take on most of them. Claude, for example, is already very effective at informed market research.

Let’s look at a few core skills humans need to keep ownership of and discuss how and why they still matter.

End-user interviews: An interview - at its core - is not asking questions and writing down answers. A bot can easily do that. A toddler is also really good at asking questions - and is typically way more persistent than most of us.

An interview - at its core - is about knowing what to ask, reading the interviewee, questioning what they really are saying and asking the right follow-up questions. Non-verbal cues, such as a slight pause, can indicate that a response of “everything’s fine” really means “I don’t use it at all.”

There’s also real skill - and this is maybe the most important part of a discovery interview - in bringing the interviewee into a space where they feel comfortable being honest and open so they can provide the truest representation of what they like, don’t like and what they need.

Effective interviewing requires deep empathy, shared experiences and the ability to quickly pivot. It also requires understanding very subtle clues that are often influenced by culture and sometimes even something specific to a role or organization.

Prioritization: Decisions about what to do next are complex, dynamic, and not always based fully on logic and reason (which is okay). Just like an interview, a good prioritization decision often involves incorporating information that is not always black and white, not always clear and not always on paper.

Market data may say one thing. The direction of the industry may say another. And the CEO may say a third.

A well-designed AI assistant can help you work through what you need to think about in terms of prioritization. (Just make sure the assistant is designed to be adversarial - more on that in a later post.) But human input - your input - is still core to making the right decision. And it’s also core to effectively explaining that decision.

Influence and communicating a vision: A lot of what a great product manager does is going from a solid idea to convincing colleagues that the solid idea will move the organization in the right direction. Innovation, after all, needs to challenge the status quo and is often risky.

You’ve gathered great end-user insights. AI has written the scope documents and tickets. You’ve prioritized the roadmap. AI has drafted a stunning deck to communicate the roadmap. But you still need to get it funded (whether internally or externally).

Again, empathy, a deep understanding of who you're selling to and an ability to connect widely disparate information are what make this work. A great product manager gets a bold and maybe risky (but calculated) new initiative funded because they understand the stakeholders, they understand what the stakeholders need and they understand how and why the outcome of the initiative will empower and delight end users.

If AI will take the strategy, market research and alignment work, the skills worth protecting are the ones that need you in the room: interviewing, deciding and persuading.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.

Leave a comment

Comments are reviewed before they appear. I store your name and comment, not your email.

← All patterns